Those who see the humanities, heavy coursework and value of a Harvard education as gravely imperiled can take heart in the phenomenon that is Humanities 10.
On a Tuesday morning in October, Samantha Matherne paced as she marked up on a white board explaining the philosophical underpinnings of Jane Austen’s “Emma,” with segues into Adam Smith and Immanuel Kant.
The philosophy professor posed big questions to the 90 students gathered in Boylston Hall: “Why did Austen create such an unlikable heroine?” she asked. “Why read novels at all?” And finally, as the 75-minute lecture ended, “What will become of Emma—and what will become of you?”
The students burst into applause.
Samantha Matherne holding her copy of "Emma" along with a handout from the class.Pamela Paul/WSJ
Hum 10, as it’s commonly known, has become the surprise hit of Harvard’s academic lineup and something of a campus institution. Demand to get into the class has surged, fueled by word-of-mouth from “Hum Alums” who talk it up on social media. Applications (essays required) shot up 40% this fall with 180 incoming freshmen vying for 90 spots.
It’s a fever that even the professors are struggling to explain.
The class is definitely not for padding the GPA. Students read a hefty book a week and write regular essays. There is no pass/fail option. Digital devices are verboten, and attendance is taken in every lecture (pink slips for those who arrive late).
“I did have the sense that a lot of students feel that the culture at large is not hospitable to deep reading, deep thinking or deep engagement with writing,” said David Elmer, a classics professor and one of Hum 10’s co-leads. “Whether that’s because of AI encroaching on their autonomy as a writer or thinker, I honestly don’t know.”
It’s all distinctly old school. Hotly contested terms like “Western Civ,” “Great Books” and “the canon” appear nowhere in the course description. But the curriculum begins with “The Odyssey,” travels forward in time to James Joyce’s “Ulysses” and then backward to end with “The Iliad.” In between are assignments on Montaigne, Shakespeare, Spinoza, Baldwin, Dante and Plato.
Advertisement
Hum 10 is the surprise hit of Harvard's academic lineup, with 180 freshmen vying for 90 spots. Pamela Paul/WSJ
In their applications and in interviews, students expressed the urge to be forced to tackle classics they otherwise wouldn’t read, the need to combat frayed attention spans and the desire for an antidote to The Machine. Several mentioned with disdain that people who aren’t in the class wondered why they didn’t “just Chat the books,” i.e., use AI.
“A lot of what we get out of this class is the human experience, and you can’t get that out of AI,” said Peggy Urdan, a government and neuroscience major from Lexington, Mass. “The only way to get anything out of this class is to not use AI.”
At the core of the humanities is, of course, humanity.
Dreamed up over dinner in 2008 by friends Stephen Greenblatt and Louis Menand, both renowned English professors and bestselling authors, Hum 10 was conceived as a Harvard twist on a famed Columbia senior seminar and Yale’s Directed Studies program, and a way to combat plummeting student interest in the humanities.
Advertisement
The course has since expanded to a rotating cast of Harvard’s loftiest faculty members, each of whom lead two lectures and a weekly seminar. Faculty have included historian Jill Lepore and novelist and critic Namwali Serpell. Matherne and Elmer took over after Menand and Greenblatt, who still regularly teach the class, passed the baton in 2023.
Faculty from left: Jay Harris, Joyce Chaplin, Jesse McCarthy, Stephen Greenblatt, David Elmer, Samantha Matherne. Not pictured: Louis Menand. Pamela Paul/WSJ
“Being able to read ‘Hamlet’ with Greenblatt is like being able to cook with Julia Child,” said Naomi Beinart, an intended government (“and maybe history”) major from New York.
Hum 10 professors cited the same pleasure.
“I was both elated and terrified that not only did I have to give lectures in front of students, but also the Pulitzer Prize winners on the teaching team who would decide if I would get tenure or not,” Matherne said. “We tell students all the time that Hum 10 is a transformative experience. And not just for them.”
It’s also a lot of work. Each professor nominates two books to include among the year’s coursework. They all attend every lecture and must lead seminars on books they may not have previously read, and from other disciplines. Essentially, they are students too.
Advertisement
Nonetheless, they’re eager to be part of an elite teaching team. Jay Harris, a professor of Jewish Studies, has been teaching Hum 10 since 2015.
“I love it,” he said, dashing into class.
Stephen Greenblatt said seeing incoming students’ enthusiasm is “magical.” Pamela Paul/WSJ
“From the faculty point of view, part of the fun is that this isn’t a course in which one is going around the track for the 150th time,” Greenblatt said. “I’ve never taught ‘The Wealth of Nations’ before but that’s what made it so exciting for me to read.”
For senior faculty accustomed to teaching jaded upperclassmen, exposure to first-years is a tonic. “It’s totally magical to teach incoming students who are filled with their enthusiasm and the newness of it all,” said Greenblatt, who has taught at Harvard since 1998.
Greenblatt’s seminars, which are held at Harvard’s Fogg Museum, begin with students selecting works of art from the collection inspired by that week’s reading. Participation in the subsequent discussion was lively; students seemed to especially relish debating their classmates, often starting with “I want to push back on that a little” or “I 100% disagree.”
Advertisement
Greenblatt’s seminars begin with students selecting works of art from Harvard’s Fogg Museum. Pamela Paul/WSJ
“If you don’t have the work ethic, I don’t think you should be taking this class,” said Jaiden Hsu, an aspiring opera singer from Chicago. Most students complete most of the assigned reading, if not always on time. A few copped to skimming one or two of the denser books.
“It’s the only class I took at Harvard where people would call each other out for not having done the reading,” said Ellie Powell, a Hum Alum who graduated in 2025. “You didn’t want to disappoint the seminar by being the one person who didn’t read or whose comment really didn’t add to the discussion. We all felt like we were building something, and that was a remarkable feeling.”
The Brutal Harvard Class That Suddenly Everyone Wants to Take
It’s an ungodly amount of reading and no easy A. So why are freshmen lining up to get into Humanities 10?
Those who see the humanities, heavy coursework and value of a Harvard education as gravely imperiled can take heart in the phenomenon that is Humanities 10.
On a Tuesday morning in October, Samantha Matherne paced as she marked up on a white board explaining the philosophical underpinnings of Jane Austen’s “Emma,” with segues into Adam Smith and Immanuel Kant.
The philosophy professor posed big questions to the 90 students gathered in Boylston Hall: “Why did Austen create such an unlikable heroine?” she asked. “Why read novels at all?” And finally, as the 75-minute lecture ended, “What will become of Emma—and what will become of you?”
The students burst into applause.
Samantha Matherne holding her copy of "Emma" along with a handout from the class.Pamela Paul/WSJ
Hum 10, as it’s commonly known, has become the surprise hit of Harvard’s academic lineup and something of a campus institution. Demand to get into the class has surged, fueled by word-of-mouth from “Hum Alums” who talk it up on social media. Applications (essays required) shot up 40% this fall with 180 incoming freshmen vying for 90 spots.
It’s a fever that even the professors are struggling to explain.
The class is definitely not for padding the GPA. Students read a hefty book a week and write regular essays. There is no pass/fail option. Digital devices are verboten, and attendance is taken in every lecture (pink slips for those who arrive late).
“I did have the sense that a lot of students feel that the culture at large is not hospitable to deep reading, deep thinking or deep engagement with writing,” said David Elmer, a classics professor and one of Hum 10’s co-leads. “Whether that’s because of AI encroaching on their autonomy as a writer or thinker, I honestly don’t know.”
It’s all distinctly old school. Hotly contested terms like “Western Civ,” “Great Books” and “the canon” appear nowhere in the course description. But the curriculum begins with “The Odyssey,” travels forward in time to James Joyce’s “Ulysses” and then backward to end with “The Iliad.” In between are assignments on Montaigne, Shakespeare, Spinoza, Baldwin, Dante and Plato.
Advertisement
Hum 10 is the surprise hit of Harvard's academic lineup, with 180 freshmen vying for 90 spots. Pamela Paul/WSJ
In their applications and in interviews, students expressed the urge to be forced to tackle classics they otherwise wouldn’t read, the need to combat frayed attention spans and the desire for an antidote to The Machine. Several mentioned with disdain that people who aren’t in the class wondered why they didn’t “just Chat the books,” i.e., use AI.
“A lot of what we get out of this class is the human experience, and you can’t get that out of AI,” said Peggy Urdan, a government and neuroscience major from Lexington, Mass. “The only way to get anything out of this class is to not use AI.”
At the core of the humanities is, of course, humanity.
Dreamed up over dinner in 2008 by friends Stephen Greenblatt and Louis Menand, both renowned English professors and bestselling authors, Hum 10 was conceived as a Harvard twist on a famed Columbia senior seminar and Yale’s Directed Studies program, and a way to combat plummeting student interest in the humanities.
Advertisement
The course has since expanded to a rotating cast of Harvard’s loftiest faculty members, each of whom lead two lectures and a weekly seminar. Faculty have included historian Jill Lepore and novelist and critic Namwali Serpell. Matherne and Elmer took over after Menand and Greenblatt, who still regularly teach the class, passed the baton in 2023.
Faculty from left: Jay Harris, Joyce Chaplin, Jesse McCarthy, Stephen Greenblatt, David Elmer, Samantha Matherne. Not pictured: Louis Menand. Pamela Paul/WSJ
“Being able to read ‘Hamlet’ with Greenblatt is like being able to cook with Julia Child,” said Naomi Beinart, an intended government (“and maybe history”) major from New York.
Hum 10 professors cited the same pleasure.
“I was both elated and terrified that not only did I have to give lectures in front of students, but also the Pulitzer Prize winners on the teaching team who would decide if I would get tenure or not,” Matherne said. “We tell students all the time that Hum 10 is a transformative experience. And not just for them.”
It’s also a lot of work. Each professor nominates two books to include among the year’s coursework. They all attend every lecture and must lead seminars on books they may not have previously read, and from other disciplines. Essentially, they are students too.
Advertisement
Nonetheless, they’re eager to be part of an elite teaching team. Jay Harris, a professor of Jewish Studies, has been teaching Hum 10 since 2015.
“I love it,” he said, dashing into class.
Stephen Greenblatt said seeing incoming students’ enthusiasm is “magical.” Pamela Paul/WSJ
“From the faculty point of view, part of the fun is that this isn’t a course in which one is going around the track for the 150th time,” Greenblatt said. “I’ve never taught ‘The Wealth of Nations’ before but that’s what made it so exciting for me to read.”
For senior faculty accustomed to teaching jaded upperclassmen, exposure to first-years is a tonic. “It’s totally magical to teach incoming students who are filled with their enthusiasm and the newness of it all,” said Greenblatt, who has taught at Harvard since 1998.
Greenblatt’s seminars, which are held at Harvard’s Fogg Museum, begin with students selecting works of art from the collection inspired by that week’s reading. Participation in the subsequent discussion was lively; students seemed to especially relish debating their classmates, often starting with “I want to push back on that a little” or “I 100% disagree.”
Advertisement
Greenblatt’s seminars begin with students selecting works of art from Harvard’s Fogg Museum. Pamela Paul/WSJ
“If you don’t have the work ethic, I don’t think you should be taking this class,” said Jaiden Hsu, an aspiring opera singer from Chicago. Most students complete most of the assigned reading, if not always on time. A few copped to skimming one or two of the denser books.
“It’s the only class I took at Harvard where people would call each other out for not having done the reading,” said Ellie Powell, a Hum Alum who graduated in 2025. “You didn’t want to disappoint the seminar by being the one person who didn’t read or whose comment really didn’t add to the discussion. We all felt like we were building something, and that was a remarkable feeling.”